April 28, 2024
stick figure with megaphone shouting political topics by Leah Fisher Nyfeler

When a Debate Isn’t Really a Discussion

Somehow, at some point over the years, my dad began to see me as the embodiment of every liberal politician he can’t stand.

Now, I’m certainly the left-leaning, “yellow dog” Democrat of the family. And I frequently try to provide counter-balancing insight to whatever topic is at hand. The problem is, lately, who I am has become lost in his “debates.”

My feelings came out in today’s blackout poems.

blackout poem Masks by Leah Fisher Nyfeler
she doesn’t want to disrupt / but what good / is noticed / when invisible / through a mask

The Greek tragedy masks represent my stand-in role. I’m not me; he’s addressing whichever liberal currently needs a beat-down. Whatever points I may try to make are but a disruption to the lecture.

So I put on a complacent mask and warily dodge comments and remain aloof. Until I can’t anymore. And then, because I speak up, I’m the bad guy who’s turned the “discussion” into an argument.

Now, I’m a grown woman who understands her options. I can

  • sit quietly and take it
  • argue thoughtfully
  • get up and leave
  • not show up

I love my dad, so not showing up isn’t a real option. Unfortunately, he seeks out these “debates.” At various points, I’ve implemented the first three tactics. Doing so hasn’t made me feel good–though, of the three, “leaving” makes me feel least bad. But I also feel alone. Imagine: family time=essentially absenting yourself.

Nobody likes being the focal point for anyone’s anger, and this constant scapegoating hurts. When everyone else sits by silently (or joins in to pile it on), I see the rest of my family supporting this treatment.

So poem #2:

blackout poem the heart cracks and hardens by Leah Fisher Nyfeler
the heart cracks and hardens / so many big and small things / to break me / in the same shouted voices / I knew / I live alone

I know my dad’s not going to change. And probably no one else will. It’s up to me to figure out how to best take care of myself.

 

(Visited 485 times, 1 visits today)

Leah Nyfeler

I'm a writer, content marketer, and adventurer who is always looking for the another story, exciting adventure, new trail, and good meal/book/movie. I love sharing things I'm curious about, what I know, and how I've come to learn it. Read my blog, "Enjoying the Journey: Observations on the Fit Life" (leahruns100.com) and find my articles in a variety of print and online magazines.

View all posts by Leah Nyfeler →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.